20 Mar 2011 - NUS Arts Fest – Kaiyin's Concert

As Victor's performance ended at 8, and the doors for Kaiyin's Varsity Voices: A Musical Tapestry opened at 8 as well, so it was all good. I actually went in feeling pretty good about the place, thinking 'hey, singapore's music scene isn't THAT dead after all,' and stuff like that. Then the show started, and the MCs ruined my mood.

Perhaps i'm too spoilt by UB. Perhaps i'm too spoilt by CJC and Cedar. But the MCs were really terrible. In particular the girl. It was like one bad joke after another, one embarrassing moment after another, my gosh. I felt myself blushing on her behalf. But anyway. On to the music.

Nelson Kwei was conducting them, and yeah, i had a certain amount of expectations from them. it was Nelson Kwei, after all. I'll just do a quick song by song review.

They started off with "Sure on this Shining Night" by Morten Lauridson with piano accompaniment. It sounded a bit like a warm-up song to me, but i suppose thats ok. I'd rather have a warm up song and better ones to follow, as opposed to no warm up song and consequently, a screwy concert.

Next, they did Javier Busto's "Ave Verum Corpus". I loved how this piece sounded very romantic, as opposed to the Ave Verum STAC normally does. I think the one we do is Mozart's version. Quite romantic, but not as much as Busto's version.

Then they did "Ave Maria" by Vytautas Miskinis. Quite a religious line up of songs, eh. haha. The response i scribbled to this was 'This reminds me of those 6 hour masses'. I can't actually remember how it sounds like, but i suppose it must have sounded quite draggy and performance-like, probably highlighting the choir as opposed to the lyrics. Typical of that era when church choirs were all the rage, and people spent their entire afternoon in the church enjoying the choir as opposed to celebrating the mass. I can't remember it exactly either, but i remember Leonard mentioning it. Probably sounded elaborate and boring.

Then they did Kalinda. It was supposed to be tribal, but being Singapore, we are never raw enough to do these type of genres. Tribal, gospel, etc. Its just beyond us. This was no exception, with a weak sounding tribe. God probably didn't hear their praise. Additionally, it was messy at points. Not well done.

Then they did La Luna by Stroope, with flute and oboe accompaniment. It was quite painful to listen to this in my opinion, as the two soloists 1)weren't confident, and 2)were overpowering the choir. They couldn't control their dynamics, and sounded mf through all their parts. perhaps they attempted dynamics, but i couldn't discern it from where i was seated. The lack of blending among all the 3 types of sounds made it a highly uncomfortable experience for me.

Then they did The Spheres by Ola Gjeilo. My response to this was 'Kyrie'. I think it was just another version of the Latin Mass Order 'Kyrie'. Lord have mercy, Christ have mercy, Lord have mercy.

Then they did Star of the County Down. I supposed the choir had fun performing this piece, but AGAIN, there just wasn't enough oomph in the sound. It was not spirited enough, not passionate enough. Or maybe i was just sitting in the wrong spot. :( It sounded quite lackluster.

Then finally, before the intermission, they did Chili Con Carne. Another fun song, and this time with dancing to boot. My only complaint was the final 'HA!'. Yeah it was quite fail. ahaha. I think its just hard to coordinate 80? odd singers to go HA! at the same time after a pause. Unless they are all telepathic. So yup. It was a cute song.

After the intermission, the NUS Choir did Natsu-no Enongu by Kentaro Sato. Its a pretty new song, i think, and sounded typically Japanese. It was pleasant to listen to, except that the guys' 'za-za' was a bit too loud. it was overpowering the female voices somewhat.

Next, they did 'tween Dusk and Dreams. My response to this song was one word - nice!

Then they did Chiisana Sora by Toru Takemitsu, and was performed not by the choir, but by their alumni of sorts, called the Graduate Singers. The 's' sounds weren't harmonised, like it went 's-s-s-s' instead of a single 's'. and for an alumni group, i think that is quite a basic requirement.. So i can't say that it was a good performance.

Then the Graduate Singers did Dong Dong Kui. I remember doing an SSAA version of this back in Cedar. Nostalgic. I felt it was pretty good, but they could afford to be more nasal and 乡下 sounding, to be more authentic. But nonetheless I think it was good.

Then the NUS Choir ended their repertoire with a few specially commissioned songs. Not really spectacular, in my opinion, with the first song 'Seasons' having too many long pauses, which made it sound awkward. I also expected Little Fly to be an energetic song, but it turned out to be melancholic. Hm.

Lastly, they finished off with Kruhay, another dancing song. I felt it was pretty good, just that the girl voices were a bit too gentle. But then again thats just a typical flaw in Singaporean singing, so i'll accept it.

Overall, an okay performance, much better than many secondary school choirs i've heard, but being Nelson Kwei, i was expecting a little more. More drama, more flair. But it didn't really happen. It could just as easily be the choir's fault, or my own poor judgement, but i felt that with the amount i paid, i would have been more willing to attend Victor's performance again as compared to the NUS Choir.

No comments:

Post a Comment